Garrett was arrested in 1980 and convicted for the murder of his wife, Jamie's mother. Jamie was born “Michael,” son to an addict mother and violent father. One day when Garrett found an infant Jamie sucking on a crack pipe while his mother was with another man, Garrett killed her.
The underlying reason for John Dutton's dislike of Jamie is their differing personality and views on life. It is why they often fight, argue, and even work against each other in various stages of their life. Of course, it's also possible that John dislikes Jamie because he's adopted and not a true-blooded Dutton.
Click here for the main page of the Randall family. Jamie was born in Bozeman, MT, as James Michael Randall to Garrett and Phyllis Randall. His father beat his mother to death when Jamie was three months old. Jamie was then adopted by Evelyn Dutton and her husband John, and he came to live with a ranching family.
Garrett Randall, played by Will Patton, was Jamie Dutton's biological father and season four's major antagonist. Garrett Randall, a former ranch hand, was found guilty of murdering his wife when Jamie was a little kid. He lived alone on his farm after getting out of prison.
If she indeed knew about his adoption, she would have used every chance to bring it up. Beth came to know about Jamie and his secret only in season 4. While it was sprung upon us, it is hard to believe that she knew all along. News must have been passed on to her after Jamie's own discovery.
While she is scared that it may damage her relationship with Rip, Beth does tell him about her being sterile. In response, Rip assures her that his feelings toward her won't change, even if they can't have biological children.
'Yellowstone' Season 5, Episode 4 Recap: Beth Discovers Jamie's Secret Son and Plots Her Revenge.
Phyllis Mary Randall was Phyllis Mary Dutton, John's sister.”
For anyone wondering why does Beth hate Jamie in Yellowstone the answer is multi-layered but perhaps the biggest factor is that she holds him responsible for her being unable to have biological children.
When Jamie confronts him, Garrett admits to organizing the hit—and implies he would do it again. Jamie's discovery, however, is never revealed to any other Dutton until the season's final episodes when Beth visits Riggins herself and then confronts Jamie.
Yellowstone Season 2. Years later, Beth still blames herself for her mother's death because she didn't step in to help. Even during the flashback scene at the start of the episode, a young Beth (played by Kylie Rogers) explained to Rip how it impacted her: "I killed my mother by being scared.
She also despises Jamie for continuously betraying the family that adopted him and took him in as one of their own — in spite of the Duttons' despising of Jamie. More than anything, Beth cherishes and loved her father, making it blatantly obvious that anyone that acts against him, is her enemy — even her brother.
According to a reveal by Yellowstone stars, Jamie believes he acted in his sister's best interest by having Beth sterilized. Taking her to an abortion clinic at the Indian Reservation was the only way to keep the incident from John and protect Rip as well.
Jamie then learns that his biological father Garrett is responsible for ordering the attacks on the Duttons. Jamie keeps this information to himself, however, Beth later learns the true identity of the attacker after paying a visit to Riggins in jail.
How Did John Know Jamie's Biological Mother? In season three, John reveals that he knew Jamie's mother Phyllis before she married Garrett Randall. While nothing else is known about their relationship and how they knew each other, many fans have their theories.
She's been beaten, threatened with sexual assault, blown up, and thanks to her half-brother Jamie (Wes Bentley) underwent forced sterilization as a teenager.
Rip Wheeler and Jamie aren't related by blood, and if we're being honest, there's not a lot that connects them except for the Dutton name, neither of which was given to either of them by blood. They both swore to John Dutton that they'd protect the family and its reputation.
Christina would go on to become a mainstay and Jamie's original love interest in the show into (and throughout) Season 2. And by the end of that season, she was pregnant with Jamie's child. Like many'a Yellowstone love interest, Christina was no fan of Jamie's Dutton family, either.
Yellowstone Season 5 Episode 4: Beth's Sterilization and Monica's Baby.
After taking her to an abortion clinic that left her sterile, Beth blames Jamie for not being able to have children, which is compounded by Jamie's actions as an adult when he becomes a double-crossing lawyer (and later Attorney General).
Rip saving Beth's life
She manages to get a text sent to Rip saying "office help" just before they start savagely beating her and her assistant, Jason.