The underlying reason for John Dutton's dislike of Jamie is their differing personality and views on life. It is why they often fight, argue, and even work against each other in various stages of their life. Of course, it's also possible that John dislikes Jamie because he's adopted and not a true-blooded Dutton.
Why Does John Dutton Not Like Jamie? The main reason why John Dutton doesn't love Jamie is their differing personality and views on many issues. They often argue, fight, and work against each other. Also, a potential reason why John doesn't like Jamie is that he is not a true Dutton, but adopted.
John said in season 3, “When he married the woman who gave birth to you, we begged her not to do it because we knew…But I guess she thought she could save him.” It is possible that the Duttons adopted Jamie so that Garrett could no longer reach and harm him.
He was even set to run for Governor until his father lost faith in Jamie because that's the only thing that John Dutton ever does with Jamie: Lose faith in him. Despite his fealty to the family, Jamie has never been able to regain his father's trust despite all his efforts.
He went to Harvard, became a prominent lawyer, and protected his family to the best of his abilities. And yet, all the Duttons have given him is mistrust, abuse, and hatred. The Dutton family hates Jamie because he is not a true Dutton.
It is later revealed that part of what drove them apart was that Kayce got Monica pregnant and they planned to keep the baby. That is when John forced Kayce to take the brand. Before the series, he was an ex-Navy SEAL who settled on the Broken Rock Reservation with his wife Monica and son Tate.
However, John misinterpreted their friendly intimacy as something more, only to be rejected, and it became clear that the quietly-spoken soldier was already in love with Jamie as he sat alone afterwards, a single tear running down his face.
In the episode of Yellowstone "The Dream Is Not Me" (S5, E7), Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley) is preparing to disrupt a dynasty.
But when the rubber meets the road - Jamie realizes that it's difficult to keep his promises. Because the fact that it was Lord John that Claire turned to - that somehow cuts Jamie deep. Clearly he still loves Claire, understands what she did, and forgives her for it - but here, in this passage, he admits he is human.
They often argue, fight, and work against each other. Also, a potential reason why John doesn't like Jamie is that he is not a true Dutton, but adopted. In season three, Jamie learns that he is not John's biological son.
Family & marriage
John and Evelyn Dutton were blessed with three more children: Kayce has two brothers (Lee and Jamie) and a sister (Beth).
Why Did the Duttons Adopt Jamie? After being sentenced to jail, Garrett hoped that his son would have a better life with a different family who could love him and provide for him.
He is the elder son of Tywin Lannister, twin brother of Cersei, with whom he has a longstanding incestuous relationship, and brother of Tyrion. Although Jaime first appears to be unscrupulous and immoral, he later proves to be more complex, honorable, and sympathetic.
Yellowstone season 4 ended with the Duttons not knowing about Jamie's baby and Cristina not knowing that Jamie killed Garrett (and that Beth and John practically own Jamie's life) - but these secrets are bound to get revealed sooner or later.
Jamie, of course, finds out that Riggins' previous cellmate was Garrett Randall, Jamie's biological father. When Jamie confronts him, Garrett admits to organizing the hit—and implies he would do it again.
It turns out she was hard on her because she wanted to toughen her up. Evelyn even said something to Beth the day the young girl got her first period. Evelyn says that everything will change for Beth starting that day. She made her aware that she was entering a world dominated by men.
Garrett Randall was the birth father of Jamie Dutton and the primary antagonist for Season 4. He was convicted of killing his wife when Jamie was a young boy and lived by himself on his farm after being released from prison. He blamed drugs on his wife's death and the reason for her death.
It was there that the friendship began to blossom over weekly chats. It was over one of these chats that John professed his feelings for Jamie. Even though Jamie was unable to return the romantic sentiment it's proven as time goes on that Jamie does love John, similar to the way that Claire loves Frank upon her return.
Jamie Kissed Lord John After He Refused His Body
In the show, it ended at that, to deviate from the audience's expectation, and to focus instead on true friendship and compassion. But in the book, Jamie kissed Lord John after he refused his body, intimately but not in a sexual way.
John is pleased to see "Mrs. Malcolm," but shocked when she introduces her husband Jamie. Later that night, Claire sees Lord John Grey embracing Jamie tightly, and realizes at once that John has feelings for Jamie. She angrily confronts John, who admits his feelings for Jamie and tells her about William Ransom.
Tate Dutton is a main character on Yellowstone and the child of Monica and Kayce Dutton.
She knows Kayce killed her brother. When Kayce protests that he had no choice, Monica points out he never had to be there in the first place. Monica wants to protect Tate by keeping him away from Kayce and John and will take him away from Kayce to do so.
Beth finally learns another deep family secret: John Dutton has been chucking corpses on the Montana border for years; in fact, the episode began with a young Rip (Kyle Red Silverstein), who at the urging of a young John Dutton (Josh Lucas), discards the body of a cowboy who got a little too lippy about his beloved ...