The Round Brilliant cut is generally the most expensive diamond ring shape due to high demand, the significant waste of rough diamond material (around 50% lost during cutting), and the intricate skill needed to achieve maximum sparkle (facets). Its popularity for engagement rings and superior brilliance drives its premium price per carat compared to other shapes like Princess or Cushion cuts.
Round brilliant diamonds are the most expensive, not just because they're the most sought after, but also because they involve more material loss and require exact cutting. As a result, round diamonds can cost 25–35% more than fancy shapes of the same carat, color, and clarity.
Ranking number one as the most affordable diamond shape, cushion-cut diamonds are a great choice for an elegant yet price-conscious purchase. Price-savvy brides adore cushion cut diamonds and this elegant shape has been experiencing a serious revival in popularity over the last few years.
The round cut is the most popular and traditional engagement ring shape. Its circular form maximises brilliance and fire, making it a timeless choice.
When it comes down to what typically makes an engagement ring cost the most, all eyes are on the center stone. This gem, resting proudly at the center, is often the part that grabs everyone's attention. But it doesn't just charm with its sparkle. It also represents the highest cost in the ring layout.
Manufacturing defects, such as scratches, dents, or uneven finishes, can make a ring look cheap. High-quality rings should have smooth surfaces and flawless finishes, free from any visible imperfections.
The national average cost of an engagement ring hovers around $5,000, but prices can vary significantly based on factors like the cut, carat, clarity, and setting of the diamond. Being informed about the average costs at a jewelry store will help you determine the baseline for what you might expect to spend.
Classic Engagement Ring Designs That Never Go Out of Style
Classic Cushion and Round Diamond Trilogy Ring
Meghan's original engagement ring was estimated to be 4.5 carats. The ring consists of a three-carat cushion-cut centre stone, with two round-cut side stones, with each stone being approximately 0.75 carats each.
To flatter and compliment shorter fingers, selecting elongated shapes like oval, pear, and marquise diamonds draw the eye vertically, helping to visually lengthen the appearance of the finger. Rectangular shapes, such as emerald or radiant cuts, can also have a similar effect.
The Aquamarine name comes from the Latin word for seawater and is said to calm waves and keep sailors safe at sea. It is sometimes referred to as a poor man's diamond because of the pale color.
Round brilliant cut is the most sparkly of all shapes. Cut grades range from Poor to Excellent, with symmetry and polish affecting performance. Fancy shapes like oval, cushion, and princess offer unique sparkle patterns. Always prioritize cut quality over size for maximum shine.
1. The Koh-I-Noor — Unknown. Topping our list of the most expensive diamonds in the world is the legendary Koh-I-Noor. Weighing in at a massive 105.6ct, the most expensive diamond in the world is oval-shaped.
While the round brilliant cut holds the top spot, other diamond shapes also come with a substantial price tag, though generally lower than round cuts.
A5 Japanese Kobe Beef
In fact, it's usually considered the most expensive steak in the world, although prices vary by location, restaurant, etc.
The marquise diamond shape typically looks the largest per carat. Its elongated, boat-shaped cut features pointed ends with a large surface area visible from the top view. This shape's distinctive design can make a 1-carat marquise diamond appear significantly larger than a 1-carat round brilliant of the same weight.
Size is subjective and varies depending on personal preference and budget (and even things like finger size, if you're looking at engagement rings!). However, diamonds of one carat and above are typically considered large.
Hailey Bieber's ring has a traditional oval cut diamond. Oval-shaped diamonds, created in the early 1960s, have become trendsetting gemstones that are currently the most sought diamonds of the year. They have become the ideal diamond and are gaining popularity with celebrities as the go-to diamond for engagement rings.
Meghan Markle has publicly shared that she experienced postpartum preeclampsia, a serious and rare condition involving high blood pressure and excess protein in the urine that occurred after childbirth, describing it as a "huge medical scare". She revealed this on her podcast, Confessions of a Female Founder, highlighting the life-threatening nature of the disorder, which can happen weeks after delivery and impact new mothers' ability to care for their newborns.
For around $5,000, you can typically find a natural diamond ranging from 0.5 to 1.5 carats, depending heavily on quality (the 4Cs), cut, setting cost, and if it's lab-grown, but a good quality 1-carat diamond often starts near this price point. A $5,000 budget could get you a significant stone like a 1-carat diamond or even larger lab-grown options, but quality factors (color, clarity) will significantly impact size and price.
9 Popular Engagement Ring Trends You Should Avoid, According to 7 Expert Jewelers
11 Most Popular Engagement Ring Trends for 2026
Best Times of Year to Shop