Surgery for a rotator cuff tear is considered when pain and weakness persist despite non-surgical treatments (like physio/meds) for 6-12 months, especially for larger tears (over 3 cm), full-thickness tears, or tears from acute injury, particularly in younger, active people, as tears can worsen and become irreparable over time, leading to arthritis. While small tears might heal non-surgically, significant tears, especially full-thickness ones, often need repair to restore function and prevent further damage.
Full thickness rotator cuff tear
Complete rotator tears are most often divided into four categories using the Codman classification, based on the size of the tear from front to back (anterior to posterior). These are: Small: 0 to 3 cm. Medium: 1 cm to 3 cm.
It is very uncommon to operate on a partial rotator cuff tear. In cases of deep partial tears — when more than 90 percent of the tendon is torn — surgery is recommended only if the symptoms can't be controlled with nonsurgical treatments.
At what point does a rotator cuff tear require surgery? Surgery is recommended: If you have persistent (ongoing) pain or weakness in your shoulder that does not improve with nonsurgical treatment, including a dedicated course of physical therapy.
Pain extends down to the elbow, but usually not any further. Neck pain on the same side may develop over time, as well as low dull headaches. There is progressive weakness of shoulder motion. Patients may hear a cracking in the shoulder or have difficulty getting dressed or lying on the injured shoulder.
Constant pain is one of the most common signs of a torn rotator cuff. The pain may be felt in the shoulder and upper arm, and can range from a dull ache to a sharp, stabbing sensation. The shoulder pain may also worsen when the arm is raised overhead or moved in certain positions.
Those are small to medium tears. Patients still have the ability to raise their arm, and they can still do day-to-day things, but they tend to have some pain. So, being able to use the arm and move it and raise it above your head does not necessarily mean that the rotator cuff is intact.
You may not be a good candidate if: Your shoulder pain is due to stiffness or joint disease, but does not rotator cuff damage. Your muscle tissue is weak including muscle loss or shortening. You are older than 65.
McCarty noted that physical therapy doesn't repair rotator cuff tears so much as teach patients to use uninjured muscles to move the shoulder efficiently and painlessly.
If you are dealing with rotator cuff issues, you can reduce pain by sleeping on your back rather than on your side. You can even elevate your injured shoulder in this position by placing a folded towel or pillow underneath it, reducing swelling and inflammation.
Your doctor may offer surgery as an option for a torn rotator cuff if your pain does not improve with nonsurgical methods. Continued pain is the main reason for having surgery. However, your doctor may also suggest surgery if you are very active and use your arms for overhead work or sports.
Grade 1 (mild): Your tendon is stretched more than normal, but it can still stabilize your foot and ankle. You may have mild tenderness and swelling. Grade 2 (moderate): Your tendon has a partial tear, and you have moderate tenderness and swelling.
It is well known that rotator cuff surgery is a major operation where the rotator cuff tendons (Figure 1) are sewn back to the upper arm bone (humerus) (Figures 2 and 3).
Complete (or full-thickness) rotator cuff tears
A complete or full-thickness tear is much more severe. In this type of tear, the tendon is completely detached (torn away) from the bone, either fully (a full-thickness complete tear) or partly (a full-thickness incomplete tear).
You may not need surgery if: Your shoulder gets better with physiotherapy. You have a torn rotator cuff but you are not in pain. You can do your daily activities.
An arthroscopic rotator cuff surgery may take around 1 to 1.5 hours, whereas an open surgery may take around 1.5 to 2 hours.
The "7 Minute Rotator Cuff Solution" refers to a well-known book by Joseph Horrigan and Jerry Robinson, offering a quick, gentle exercise program to prevent and rehab shoulder injuries by improving blood flow, joint lubrication, and strengthening the rotator cuff muscles, focusing on decompression and proper shoulder mechanics, often using simple movements like towel stretches or light resistance. While the specific book content is detailed, the core idea is a short, daily routine of targeted exercises (mobility, light strengthening) to decompress the joint, lubricate it, and build basic muscle support, emphasizing consistency and proper form.
Rest and Rehabilitation
Often, doctors will recommend immobilizing the shoulder with a sling to restrict movement during the initial healing phase. Once the inflammation has subsided, rehabilitation exercises play a pivotal role in strengthening the affected muscles and restoring mobility.
Only about 10-20% of rotator cuff tears need surgery, as most people manage well with treatments like physical therapy. Many with partial tears or mild symptoms find relief without surgery, showing that most rotator cuff injuries don't require surgical repair.
But in general, rotator cuff surgery has a little bit longer recovery with a little bit more pain on the front end than replacement. Take control of your shoulder health. Schedule a visit with Dr. Kevin Kruse at (469) 804-5977 today.
One relatively new treatment is the InSpace balloon implant for irreparable rotator cuff tears. This technique is especially helpful for older adults who may not handle more invasive surgeries well. Studies show it can reduce symptoms and help improve function during rehabilitation.
Injections around the rotator cuff are helpful in providing relief, restoring function, and facilitating rehabilitation. However, partial and complete rotator cuff tears will not heal with cortisone injections and can make them worse. In fact, injections may compromise healing after surgery.
Structural integrity after rotator cuff repair did not affect final clinical outcome. Even in elderly patients aged ≥ 75 years, high healing rate of a repaired RCT over 85% was shown in cases of small to medium tears.