The rarest Cow Squishmallow often considered a top collectible is Connor the Cow, especially older or specific versions (like the 2018 8-inch), but others like Tuluck the Blue Cow (Easter Ultra Rare) and limited editions like Griella (no bow) or Caedyn also rank as very hard to find and valuable. Rarity shifts with releases, but classic Connor and unique variations are consistently sought after.
The rarest Squishmallow cow is Connor. Unlike other stuffed animals, Connor's patches are black, and he has pink ears and a pink muzzle.
The rarest Squishmallows are highly sought-after collector's items, often limited-edition drops like Kiki the Kool-Aid Duck, Benny the Bookworm, Luna the Lunar Rabbit, and unique prototypes such as Peach Fuzz (2017 Prototype), alongside special charity editions like Ozzie the Octopus Nurse, with values skyrocketing due to scarcity and specific event releases. Other contenders include event exclusives like Fania the Owl (once very expensive) and Blossom the Lamb (Justice exclusive), showcasing that rarity comes from limited runs and unique features.
This product is a rare and large 24" Squishmallows plush toy featuring Ronnie the Cow. The brand Squishmallows is known for its adorable and huggable stuffed animals, making this plush a sought-after collectible for fans and collectors.
Tuluck the Cow is a blue Squishmallow. His tag marks him as an Ultra Rare Squishmallow.
Cillian the Blue Easter Cow Squishmallow 8" 2023 (VERY RARE) Approx.
Top 23 Popular Squishmallows to Collect
Rarity & Availability: Connor the Cow is an active Squishmallow athlete. Though he's not the rarest Squishmallow, you may find it hard to find one these days.
Top 10 Ugly Squishmallows (User-Rated)
Louie the mango loves to read despite his dyslexia
Having “grown to love books and stories,” it's no surprise this character wants to be a librarian when he grows up. Louie sports a vibrant orange color with iridescent stripes across his belly, and the leaf on Louie's head is just as sweet as his tiny, little smile.
What Makes a Rare Squishmallow?
Original Official KellyToy Squishmallows Exclusive 5th Year Anniversary Collecctor Edition containing eight mini Squishmallows. Set includes Fifi Fox, Hans Hedgehog, Hoot Owl, Cameron Cat, Holly Owl, Puff Penguin, Piper Penguin and Wendy Frog.
Missing or Incorrect Tags
Original Squishmallows always have three small tags: Hang tag: "Original Squishmallows: Squeeze and Cuddle Me" Product tag: "Kelly Toys" branding with detailed product information. Butt tag: Unique toy's ID and batch number for authenticity verification.
What is the Rarest Squishmallow? (2024 Updated)
This is a rare and adorable Squishmallow Cow plush toy named Bodie. Made by Squishmallows, this mini plush is perfect for all occasions and ages. With its washable material, it is easy to maintain and keep clean. Bodie is a colorful and multi-sized plush toy that will definitely bring a smile to anyone's face.
KellyToy released their first ever plushies under the brand name Squishmallows in 2017. This first squad consisted of eight characters, being Cam the Cat, Wendy the Frog, Fifi the Fox, Hans the Hedgehog, Piper and Puff the Penguins, and Hoot and Holly the Owls.
Fans adore Blossom, the adorable cat with a winking expression and heart-shaped ears—often voted the cutest Squishmallow.
Thanks to their TikTok fame and extra-soft tummies, the cuddly figures are equally popular among children and young adults. Their velvety bellies feel as if they're filled with marshmallows. Their cute faces draw you in for a cuddle.
A collection of Squishmallows (or other editions of a Squishmallow) that are marked as Ultra Rare based on the Squishmallow rarity scale. They have a gold badge on their tag with a maximum of 50,000 units made.
1 out of every 496 baby boys and 1 out of every 118,632 baby girls born in 2021 are named Connor.
So here are the best, cutest, most huggable cow Squishmallows for you or whoever you're trying to buy a gift for available right now.
Retired Squishmallows
The first-ever Squishmallow was "Cam the Cat," who is part of Kelly Toy's original 2017 collection.
Rare Squishmallows are labeled with a silver tag and have a maximum of 75,000 units each available worldwide. Ultra Rare Squishmallows are labeled with a golden tag and have a maximum of 50,000 units each available worldwide.