The rarest Squishmallows are often limited-edition releases like Jack the Black Cat, the first Select Series plush with only 500 made, and other Founder's Editions, but Fania the Purple Owl, Avery the Duck, and exclusive versions like Valravn the Raven are also extremely sought after due to low production numbers or exclusive retailer releases, with values climbing significantly on resale markets.
The rarest Squishmallow is often debated, but Jack the Black Cat (from the first Select Series with only 500 made) and Golden Hans (24-inch) (only 25 produced for the 100 million milestone) are top contenders, while Jazmanian (an employee exclusive) and certain Founders Edition Squishmallows are also exceptionally rare and valuable. Rarity is determined by extremely limited production runs, exclusive releases (like employee gifts or special event items), and unique tags.
Rare Squishmallows are labeled with a silver tag and have a maximum of 75,000 units each available worldwide. Ultra Rare Squishmallows are labeled with a golden tag and have a maximum of 50,000 units each available worldwide.
Top 23 Popular Squishmallows to Collect
This first squad consisted of eight characters, being Cam the Cat, Wendy the Frog, Fifi the Fox, Hans the Hedgehog, Piper and Puff the Penguins, and Hoot and Holly the Owls.
Cam the Cat
Cameron the Cat is special. He was the first Squishmallow ever sold and a part of the first eight.
Top 10 Ugly Squishmallows (User-Rated)
Rarity & Availability: Jack the Black Cat is king of the rare Squishmallows. Initially released as part of the first Squishmallow Select Series, only 500 Jack the Black Cat plush toys were ever produced.
Opt for Certified Safe Brands:
When it comes to baby-safe stuffed animals, choosing brands that prioritize safety is crucial. Jellycat, Steiff, Squishable and Squishmallows are just a few brands renowned for their adherence to stringent safety standards.
Sheila the Chocolate Pancake Brown Squishmallow is an ultra rare 8 inch plush toy from Kellytoy.
Every Squishmallow is unique, with over 1,000 different characters made, all with unique names and background stories.
Squishmallows are expensive due to high demand driven by limited releases, popular characters, and scalpers, combined with their unique soft texture and collectible nature, making some rare editions extremely valuable on the resale market where prices skyrocket far beyond retail, especially for exclusive or retired designs like the incredibly rare Golden Hans.
What Makes a Rare Squishmallow?
Fans adore Blossom, the adorable cat with a winking expression and heart-shaped ears—often voted the cutest Squishmallow.
While Jack was thought to be one of the most sought-after squishmallows with only 500 made, there's a collector's item even more elusive that takes the title of the rarest squishmallow! Introducing JSK, the new rare sensation! 😻 This remarkable squishmallow is part of the Founders Edition, with only 250 in existence.
6 Critical Signs to Spot Fake Squishmallows
Hot dogs. This cookout staple is a choking hazard due to the tube shape and compressibility. If you do choose to give hot dogs to children, it is safest to cut them length wise and in small pieces.
What is the Rarest Squishmallow? (2024 Updated)
Original Official KellyToy Squishmallows Exclusive 5th Year Anniversary Collecctor Edition containing eight mini Squishmallows. Set includes Fifi Fox, Hans Hedgehog, Hoot Owl, Cameron Cat, Holly Owl, Puff Penguin, Piper Penguin and Wendy Frog.
SQUISHMALLOW 7.5" RUBY THE REINDEER SOFT PLUSH TOY KELLYTOYS.
STACY THE SQUID - Stacy is a shy squid, she prefers to be home with her friends or even by herself. Big groups of Squishmallows make her a little nervous, so she loves to learn and explore through books.
Rarity Scale
Thanks to their TikTok fame and extra-soft tummies, the cuddly figures are equally popular among children and young adults. Their velvety bellies feel as if they're filled with marshmallows. Their cute faces draw you in for a cuddle.