An unhealthy SCOBY typically shows signs of mold: fuzzy, dry, powdery patches in green, blue, black, or white on the surface, or a completely black, shriveled, or foul-smelling (like nail polish remover) appearance, indicating it's spoiled and needs discarding, though brown yeast spots and normal bubbles are often mistaken for mold.
A moldy or dead scoby is quite distinctive, and there is no mistaking it when you see it. The mold will be white or colorful, fuzzy and dry. It can appear as spots on the scoby, or cover the scoby altogether. A dead scoby will be black.
Signs of an unhealthy SCOBY
Those blue circles of mold are the problem, while the white circles of SCOBY growth are normal. White fuzzy dry mold is easy to spot. Powdery tan mold covers much of a new SCOBY – mold is always DRY!
With proper care, SCOBYs can last many generations. But when you see excessive, dark yeast growth on a SCOBY layer, or if it starts producing Kombucha that tastes bad or overly acidic, it's time to get a new one.
Always indicate what's in the jar so that no one in your household gets rid of it by mistake! The scoby will then go dormant and can be kept for up to 6 months. However, we've already seen scobys that had been forgotten for over a year in a corner of the fridge come back to life without any problem.
The only way to know if your kombucha scoby is dead is to test it in a new kombucha batch and wait a few weeks.
These include at least one death, a case of cardiac arrest, several cases of hepatitis, one of severe muscle weakness and inflammation of the heart muscle, and cutaneous [skin] anthrax. Lead poisoning occurred after kombucha tea, which is acidic, was brewed in ceramic containers.
Photos courtesy of Erin DiCaprio. White, grey, or pink films may form on the surface of fermenting fruits or vegetables. This film is typically yeast, often referred to by home fermenters as Kahm yeast.
Conclusion: Sunk SCOBYs Are Okay!
While a sinking SCOBY may cause concern for some brewers, it is generally not a sign of a problem, and the kombucha can still be consumed if the batch was brewed properly.
It's safe to drink pretty much indefinitely as long as it's properly brewed and stored, but that doesn't mean you'll necessarily want to drink it after it's been stored for more than a year. That's because even if it's refrigerated, it'll likely taste like vinegar at that point.
If the liquid ever looks like it's fully drying up, you should “feed” your SCOBY hotel with sweet tea or unflavored kombucha. SCOBY hotel food recipe (a.k.a. A small batch of sweet tea): Steep 1 tsp. black tea in 2 cups of water and add 2 tbsp. cane sugar.
Some people don't want any carbonation, and that's OK. You don't need to go through F2 in order to drink kombucha.
The shelf life of your kombucha is determined by the pH level, yeast growth, and alcohol content. The pH needs to stay between 2.5 and 4.2 and the alcohol content should not exceed 0.5%. Signs of yeast growth include mold that could be black, gray, brown, green, or even blue.
It is also important to “feed” the SCOBYs to keep them healthy. I add some fresh sugar tea to the hotel to keep the SCOBYs happy. Or sometimes I just “top up” with freshly harvested plain kombucha. You can do this at the same time you clean out the hotel.
You can drink kombucha daily in moderation (around 4 oz), but daily overconsumption risks headaches, nausea, excess sugar/calories, or potential lactic acidosis, especially from homemade batches with contamination risks, while its caffeine, alcohol, and acidity make it unsuitable for pregnant/breastfeeding individuals, children, or those with compromised immunity or certain health conditions.
There is also a risk of food poisoning, even with store-bought kombucha, because it does contain live, active bacteria cultures. That is why proper handling and storage are important. In general, it's probably safer to drink kombucha that you get from a trusted source rather than try to make your own.
Kombucha has a six-month “Best by” date on its canned kombucha and eight months on its glass-bottle kombucha. This means that we guarantee the flavors, fizz and naturally occurring live and active cultures to be fresh and wonderful until that date.
There are signs that you can observe to let you know the scoby is not healthy and you will need to start another batch.
How long does a SCOBY last? Put simply, kombucha SCOBYs can be reused for many years. Realistically, however, you simply won't need it to last that long. Your SCOBY grows and divides with each batch of kombucha, so you will constantly be growing new SCOBYs.
The direct answer is that you never need to replace your SCOBY if well taken care of, but when it comes to the pellicles (or “mothers” as they are so lovingly referred to), those can be thinned out with each brew.
Homemade kombucha: When properly stored in the refrigerator, homemade kombucha can generally last for up to 3 months. However, for the best flavour and fizz, it's typically recommended to consume it within 1 to 2 months of brewing. The longer it sits, the more tart it will become due to continued fermentation.
To divide, you'll simply peel away the oldest, bottom layer(s). They may separate easily, but if not it's okay to use some force. Don't worry if there are any tears or holes after dividing - the SCOBY will still get the job done. If layers do not easily separate you can also use a clean knife to cut the SCOBY in half.
Pour the cooled tea into the one gallon brewing vessel and add the bottled Kombucha. Cover the container with a paper or cloth cover held in place with a rubber band. Set in the Proofer and culture for 10 days. Scoby formation at six days.