To tell if a pearl is good quality, check for high luster (sharp, clear reflections), a clean surface (minimal blemishes like spots, bumps, or cracks), a round shape (though unique shapes have value too), size, and good nacre (the iridescent coating), with finer pearls being heavier and having a slight gritty feel against teeth (real pearl test) but a smooth look. Genuine pearls also have a slight temperature difference, feeling cool to the touch initially.
The more lustre=the more layers (you can see a pearl center under iridescent layers) , the higher the grade. The more ``perfect'' in roundness, void of flaws= higher quality. The larger the size and the richer the color=higher quality. The better the individual pearls match each other=higher quality.
The most valuable pearls are perfectly round, have excellent luster, minimal surface imperfections, and desirable colors. For example, a perfectly round South Sea pearl with a clean surface and high luster could sell for more than $10,000 in a conventional luxury setting.
The most expensive pearl colors are often deep, rich hues like Golden South Sea (especially 24k deep gold), rare Peacock Tahitian (dark green/blue/purple overtones), and intensely pink or pink-overtoned White South Sea pearls, with value heavily depending on rarity, luster, size, and lack of blemishes, rather than just the base color itself. While white and black are common, specific, saturated, and rare overtones within these categories command the highest prices.
Natural Black pearls (uncultivated) are extremely rare and are found in about 1 in every 10,000 oysters. In an effort to preserve the species, it is illegal to dive to find natural pearls.
The best pearls in Australia are the highly prized Australian South Sea Pearls, known for their large size, thick nacre, and magnificent luster, cultured from the rare Pinctada maxima oyster in the pristine waters of Western Australia, with top producers including brands like Kailis Jewellery, Paspaley, Pearls of Australia, and Willie Creek Pearls. These pearls are considered among the finest globally, with some farms also producing unique Akoya and Keshi pearls, offering exceptional quality and environmental benefits.
Pearl jewellery and pearls are not traded like gold or silver. They are considered elite gemstones and do not have a high resale value, at least as of now. Used pearl jewellery, which is sold for higher prices, is usually that which has been worn by celebrities, queens or antique pieces.
It was Jackie Kennedy who said 'pearls are always appropriate,' meaning that they suit all occasions and all outfits. Indeed pearls are still worn by many brides on their wedding days and feature in most jewellers' windows today.
Generally, you can expect to pay anywhere from $100 to $200 for a professional appraisal. Insurance appraisals are generally more expensive because they must be done by a certified gemologist and include a more detailed report.
In water, pearls do not float.
The Vinegar Test
This test is again very simple: either you put a drop of vinegar on a pearl, or submerge it in vinegar. A real pearl will dissolve in vinegar or show erosion where the vinegar drop meets its surface.
Rub the pearls to check surface feel
Both natural and cultured pearls have textured surface due to their layered nacre structure. So when you rub the pearls lightly against each other or on your front teeth, they feel a little gritty. Fake or imitation pearls, however, usually feel smooth or glassy.
Pearl is ranked 2.5 on the Mohs hardness scale, which means it's very soft and easily scratched or abraded.
People with strong or negative Mars, Saturn, or Rahu in their horoscope should avoid wearing pearls. Pearl also doesn't go well with gemstones like Gomed (Hessonite), Lehsunia (Cat's Eye), or Neelam (Blue Sapphire). If you're unsure, always get your horoscope checked before wearing a pearl stone.
Diana's love for pearls started early in her life. While her school friends often wore diamond studs, the future princess usually chose pearls. At the age of 15, Lady Diana Spencer was first seen wearing a pair of simple pearl earrings; she wore them as a bridesmaid at her sister's wedding.
“A woman needs ropes and ropes of pearls.” - Coco Chanel.
Pearl Values
Even if they're real and cost a fortune in their day, second-hand pearls aren't worth much unless there's something special about them - like they were owned by someone famous or have a unique and interesting history.
Pearls can age because they are made of biological materials. They might lose their shine, peel, or break down over time. Pearl jewelry, on the other hand, can keep its beauty and shape for hundreds of years if it is stored and cared for properly. Wearing pearl jewelry is probably the best way to keep it in good shape.
Harvesting cultured pearls often kills the oyster, as many farms kill the animals after the first harvest for their meat and shell, though some try to recycle them for multiple harvests, while wild pearl harvesting kills thousands of oysters for just a few pearls. While some techniques allow oysters to survive and produce more pearls, especially with skilled intervention, the overall industry often involves stress, harm, and eventual death for most mollusks.
Certified Hanadama Akoya pearls are the finest Akoya pearls available; there is no grade above Hanadama, and there are no “levels” within the Hanadama grade. They are all top-notch. Mikimoto, by contrast, offers four different grades of Akoya pearls, with A being the lowest and AAA being the best.
Broome: 'the pearling capital of the world'
In the 1880s pearlers turned their sights to Roebuck Bay (Broome) in the West Kimberley. By 1910 Broome was the largest pearling centre in the world, benefitting from newly introduced diving suits, fertile waters and a booming international pearl button market.