Not always; while ice cream generally has more fat, many flavored and low-fat yogurts can have just as much or even more sugar than ice cream to counteract their natural tartness, so checking nutrition labels for specific products is crucial. Often, the added sugar in frozen yogurt (froyo) can match or exceed ice cream's sugar content to improve taste and texture, making plain yogurt the best low-sugar choice, says CNN and Healthline.
The dairy in ice cream comes from cream, while frozen yogurt uses cultured milk. The result is that ice cream tends to have a higher fat content, while frozen yogurt contains more sugar to hide its tangier taste.
While frozen yogurt shops will sometimes advertise their yogurt as a healthier alternative to ice cream, people with diabetes should still only eat this dessert in moderation. Frozen yogurt may be lower in calories and fat than ice cream, but it often has more added sugar to enhance the flavor.
While yogurt naturally contains the milk sugar lactose, food companies also add sugar to further sweeten. And in many cases, sugar-sweetened fruits are added to the bottom. And then, some include toppings with even more sugar. So yogurt starts as a healthy food choice but then turns into a sugar bomb.
Short answer: yogurt is generally healthier than ice cream for most daily eating purposes because it usually contains less added sugar, less saturated fat, and more beneficial live cultures and protein. Choice depends on goals (weight, blood sugar, gut health, nutrients).
Frozen yogurt makers often claim it's a healthier alternative to ice cream, but that depends on the ingredients. It's usually lower in fat and calories than ice cream, but it can be just as high in sugar.
Greek yogurt's disadvantages include lower calcium/potassium than regular yogurt, potential histamine/inflammatory issues for some, high added sugar in flavored versions, and potential interactions with certain antibiotics, though plain, low-fat options minimize risks, making moderation and label-checking key.
Eating two to three containers of yogurt every day can add around 500 calories and close to 100 grams of sugar to the daily diet. This can cause unwanted weight gain and increase the risk of diabetes. There have been gastroenteritis outbreaks in the past because of the use of unpasteurized milk in yogurt.
Surprising Sources of Hidden Sugar
People with lactose intolerance or sensitivity may have difficulty digesting lactose, a sugar that's naturally found in milk and milk products. Frozen yogurt could be a good alternative to regular ice cream because undergoing fermentation lowers the lactose it contains.
Sugar-Free or Low-Sugar Ice Creams
Brands like Halo Top, Enlightened, and Arctic Zero are lower in total carbohydrates and often high in protein. Many brands use sugar alcohols or stevia as alternatives to traditional sweeteners.
Researchers say the worrisome part of this study is that most adults consider yogurts healthy, when in fact, most yogurts contain more sugar than a can of Coke. The best advice for those hoping for a healthy yogurt is to go Greek or natural.
5 Healthy Ice Cream Alternatives to Try This Summer
Drink more water
“Water helps your kidneys filter out excess sugar through urine,” says Khan. “So, the more hydrated you are, the more urine production you'll have, which flushes out sugar in the body.” Always opt for water instead of sugary drinks, like soda and juice.
Notably, natural/Greek yogurts had significantly lower sugar content than yogurts in all the other categories. Jessica Bennett, RD, clinical dietitian at Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Tennessee, said many yogurts have enough added sugar that they could be served as an after-dinner sweet.
8 Simple Snacks That Won't Spike Your Blood Sugar
Eating yogurt when your stomach is empty can make more stomach acid. This acid can destroy helpful probiotics in yogurt. Eat yogurt with meals or snacks to keep good bacteria safe. This helps your gut stay healthy.
The healthiest yogurts are typically plain, unsweetened Greek yogurt or Icelandic skyr, due to their high protein and probiotic content, with soy-based options being the best non-dairy alternative, all while checking labels for minimal added sugars and live cultures for gut health.
If you want a warm, savory breakfast that offers lasting fullness and nutrients like vitamin D and choline, eggs may be your best bet. If you're looking for a high-protein breakfast with probiotics, calcium and a gut-health boost, yogurt is an excellent option.
Symptoms of a yogurt and milk allergy may include hives, itching, abdominal pain, nausea, or diarrhea after eating yogurt. However, in some cases, feeling unwell after eating yogurt may be caused by lactose intolerance or other conditions that can produce similar symptoms.
Yogurt with probiotics
And it's the probiotics that can help soften stool and make you poop more often (more below on how probiotic-rich foods like yogurt are good for constipation). If you're looking for an easy meal to help you poop, consider adding fiber-rich sources to your yogurt, like fruit, nuts, or seeds.
Our study found that compared to yoghurts that contain a regular yoghurt culture (LDB) and no added probiotic, Activia Bifidobacterium lactis probiotic has 100x more survivability against the stomach acid, which means more are able to reach the gut alive, where they can exert a health benefit.