No, you generally shouldn't let a puppy cry for extended periods in their crate at night; it can increase anxiety and damage trust, but a few minutes of fussing to see if they settle is okay, especially early on. Address urgent cries (potty needs, true distress) calmly, but if they're just fussing, wait a few minutes to see if they settle, then comfort gently and return them to bed if they cry again, making the crate a positive, safe space with your presence nearby initially.
Letting them cry it out can lead to negative effects and teach the dog to suffer in silence. It is against this subs rules to even recommended that approach because of the negative effects.
The advice from dog experts is that they shouldn't be left to cry. Leaving a puppy to cry at night is likely to increase your puppy's anxiety and may lead to other behaviour problems developing, such as separation-related problems.
You could try elevating the crate and popping it next to your bed at night. Then gradually move down and away as the pup becomes more confident.
Although initially you may experience plenty of sleepless nights, it is better to ignore any barking or whining at night from the get go. As long as your dog is comfortable, it will come to no harm and this attention seeking behaviour should only last for a short time.
That's why many dog trainers and pet parents rely on nightly crate training to keep puppies safe when they cannot be actively supervised.
A blanket or crate cover can be beneficial for some dogs. It creates a den-like environment, helping them feel secure and sheltered from external stimuli.
If your puppy whines when left alone, they might not yet associate the space with good things. Don't make a habit of letting them out when they fuss. Instead, shorten the time of their confinement and then slowly build up again. remember that the pen or crate is only temporary.
Eaten from at least 7 different containers • Been held and petted by at least 7 different people • Taken at least 7 one-mile car rides • Been in a crate at least 7 times • Played with at least 7 different kinds of toys • Walked on at least 7 different substrates (grass, gravel, concrete, etc.)
Let me introduce you to the 10 , 10, 10 rule of potty training. That's cycles of 10 minutes in the yard, 10 feet of potty area in the yard, 10 minutes of supervision. It all adds up to potty training with minimal errors, even for harder to train dogs who may be struggling with other methods.
So, what exactly is this rule? It's all about limiting the initial greeting between two dogs to just three seconds. This brief interaction helps prevent overstimulation and potential conflicts. Think of it as a quick sniff and move on, allowing both dogs to assess each other without pressure.
Identifying Signs of Crate Regression
It might start with a subtle reluctance to enter their crate, followed by increased anxiety behaviors like whining or pacing. These behaviors are red flags signaling that your dog might be feeling less than enthused about their den-like retreat.
To create a positive association throw a handful of treats in the open kennel. Let your dog eat them and leave the crate on her own. As part of playtime, toss a toy in the crate occasionally, letting her go freely in and out. Next throw some treats in the crate and close the door after she gets inside.
In that case, you might remove access to water between one and two hours before bedtime and replace the water in their crate during the day. Once your puppy is fully potty trained, they should be allowed access to water according to your preferences, your dog's drinking habits, and the advice of your veterinarian.
8 Steps to Stop Your Puppy from Crying in the Crate
Provide your puppy with a comfortable bed, either in a puppy crate or somewhere that feels secure and from where they can still hear or see you. Toys that provide comfort, such as puppy-safe soft toys or chew-toys can help your puppy to self-settle when you leave them.
“The 2:1 crate rule says that for every two hours a dog spends inside their crate, they should spend one hour out of the crate,” explains Lane. “For puppies, especially those still potty training, this is generally a good rule of thumb.
6 Tips for Keeping Your Pets from Waking You Up (so You Can Finally Sleep Through the Night)
Common Crate Training Mistakes