Getting a second dog to fix separation anxiety is a risky gamble; it often doesn't work and can create two anxious dogs, as true separation anxiety stems from missing humans, not just being alone. Instead, focus on training your current dog to cope with alone time using puzzle toys, mental stimulation, and gradual departures, or consider fostering first to see how your dog handles a companion before committing to another.
While there are very rare cases in which a dog's separation anxiety is truly isolation anxiety and adopting another dog helps, in the vast majority of cases, adopting another dog does not help dogs with separation anxiety at all.
Treatment for Mild Separation Anxiety
It's done by associating the sight or presence of a feared or disliked person, animal, place, object or situation with something really good, something the dog loves. Over time, the dog learns that whatever he fears actually predicts good things for him.
The 3-3-3 rule for dogs is a guideline for the adjustment period after adoption, representing 3 days (overwhelmed/hiding), 3 weeks (settling in/testing boundaries), and 3 months (feeling at home/bonding) to help owners manage expectations and provide patience, routine, and a calm environment, understanding that anxiety is normal as they decompress from a stressful past. It's a framework for recognizing stress and fostering trust, not a rigid timeline, but it helps owners understand why a new dog might seem timid or act out initially.
A dog that isn't feeling well or is feeling lonely may also experience a lack of interest in activities they usually enjoy. If your pup isn't as enthusiastic about their walks or playing with their toys, it could also be a sign of loneliness. These are just a few of the signs that your pup may need a canine companion.
yes and no. Dogs are social animals and usually happier around other dogs, but a second dog will never be a substitute for inattentive, absent or too busy owners.
The "heartbreak breed" typically refers to the Great Dane, nicknamed this due to their loving nature combined with a significantly shorter lifespan (around 7-10 years) and predisposition to serious heart issues like Dilated Cardiomyopathy (DCM). Other breeds, like the Bernese Mountain Dog, are also called "heartbreak" dogs because of high cancer risks, while some owners find giant breeds or those with specific conditions, like Cavaliers and Pugs (heart issues), or Irish Wolfhounds (DCM), heartbreaking due to their health and mortality, despite their sweet disposition.
The most commonly surrendered dog type is the "pit bull type" (including mixes), often due to negative stereotypes, breed-specific legislation, and high energy levels, followed by other popular breeds like German Shepherds, Huskies, and Labrador Retrievers that may not fit owner lifestyles. Breeds like Staffordshire Bull Terriers (especially mixes) also top surrender lists in some regions like Australia.
Some common concerns reported by guardians of aging dogs are increased sensitivity and irritability, increased fear of unfamiliar pets and people (sometimes accompanied by aggression), decreased tolerance of touch and restraint, increased following and desire for contact, and increased anxiety when left alone.
The hardest part of adopting a rescue dog is often managing unpredictable behavioral issues and unknown pasts, requiring immense patience as you navigate their decompression, potential anxieties (separation, fear), reactivity, and lack of training, all while learning to read their subtle stress signals and adapting to their true personality emerging over weeks or months. It's a commitment to training, socialization, and healing from potential trauma, challenging unrealistic expectations set by the dog's calm shelter demeanor.
The dog breeds that are more likely to have this problem are the German Shepherd, Australian Shepherd, Border Collie, Jack Russell Terrier, Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, Bichon Frise, Toy Poodle, Labrador Retriever, Cocker Spaniel, and German Shorthaired Pointer.
Many pet owners wonder if crate training might help their dog feel more comfortable while they're away and manage their stress symptoms more effectively. Crating a dog with separation anxiety won't cure their issue, but it can be used in conjunction with other strategies to help your dog.
During the night
While the dog is still not confident to be on their own, we don't suggest leaving them on their own overnight. Placing the crate in the bedroom, close to your bed so you can reach out and comfort them even while crated, helps make the nights easier for both the dog and the family.
Getting a second dog may cause your first dog to feel displaced and uncertain. While most dogs get along with their new sibling, your first dog may be unhappy about having to share their toys, space, territory, or even their owner's affection.
7 Proven Ways to Calm Your Anxious Dog
If your dog is showing signs of separation anxiety, there are several strategies you can use to help them feel more secure.
The 3-3-3 rule for dogs is a guideline for the adjustment period after adoption, representing 3 days (overwhelmed/hiding), 3 weeks (settling in/testing boundaries), and 3 months (feeling at home/bonding) to help owners manage expectations and provide patience, routine, and a calm environment, understanding that anxiety is normal as they decompress from a stressful past. It's a framework for recognizing stress and fostering trust, not a rigid timeline, but it helps owners understand why a new dog might seem timid or act out initially.
Signs of anxiety can include:
Dog Breeds Most Likely to Bite
The Least Popular Dog Breeds in America
The calmest dog breeds often include large, gentle giants like the Saint Bernard, Newfoundland, and Great Dane, along with smaller, easygoing companions such as the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, Basset Hound, Pug, and English Bulldog, all known for their relaxed, affectionate, and laid-back temperaments, though individual dogs vary. Sighthounds like the Greyhound are also surprisingly calm indoors, needing short bursts of energy but otherwise content to lounge.
The "10 10 10 rule" for dogs refers to two main concepts: a potty training method for puppies (10 mins outside, 10 ft space, 10 mins supervision/reward) and the 80/10/10 guideline for raw feeding (80% muscle meat, 10% bone, 10% organ), both offering structure for training or diet. Another interpretation is the 10% rule for treats, limiting them to 10% of daily calories to maintain a balanced diet, ensuring most nutrition comes from complete dog food.
While there's no single "number one," the Golden Retriever and Labrador Retriever consistently rank as top friendly dogs due to their gentle, outgoing, and loyal temperaments, making them excellent family pets good with kids and other animals, though they need plenty of exercise. Other top contenders for friendliness include Cocker Spaniels, Beagles, Cavalier King Charles Spaniels, and Pugs, known for their playful, affectionate, and people-loving natures.
The 12 Most Abandoned Dog Breeds: These Pups Are Most Likely To Be Found In Shelters